2007 at 1:11 pm | posted by Rep. Craig Frank
A Fascinating Book
While in Washington DC this past week I began reading a book from a National Bestselling author—Joseph Ellis. Previously I had read Ellis’, His Excellency, George Washington. A common thread I detect through Ellis’ book points out that human nature, personality, and self-interest often drive the significant debates in Congress. People are just people. Human nature is still human nature, today, yesterday, and always. The expanse of history seems to be nothing more or less than human nature repeating itself over time.
From the Pulitzer Prize winning author Joseph Ellis’ book, Founding Brothers, regarding the Congressional debate on “Constitutional” slavery…Thomas Scott from Pennsylvania speaking for those who abhorred the practice of slavery argued that although the Constitution restricted Congress’ ability to regulate the practice, the Constitution did not preclude them from entirely abolishing slavery. Following Scott:
“(James) Jackson (from Georgia) then launched into a sermon on God’s will, which he described as patently proslavery, based on several passages in the Bible and the pronouncement of every Christian minister in Georgia. Alongside the clear preferences of the Almighty, there was the nearly unanimous opinion of every respectable citizen in his state, whose livelihood depended on the availability of slave labor and who shared the elemental recognition, as Jackson put it, ‘that rice cannot be brought to market without these people.’ William Loughton Smith preferred to leave the interpretation of God’s will to others, but he seconded the opinion of his colleague from Georgia that slavery was an economic precondition for the prosperity of his constituents, noting that ‘such is the state of agriculture in that country, no white man would perform the tasks required to drain the swamps and clear the land, so that without slaves it must be depopulated.’”
“Smith also led the debate on behalf of the Deep South on that other great text, which was not the Bible but the Constitution. In Smith’s version of the story, the framers of the Constitution had recognized that the chief source of conflict among the state delegations was between those dependent on slave labor and those free of such dependency…”
(Founding Brothers, The Revolutionary Generation, Joseph J. Ellis, Vintage, 2000, p 85)
History Repeating Itself
“Thumbing” through the newspaper this morning, I ran across an interesting article in the Deseret Morning News by Jeremy Twitchell, titled “Immigrant needs, woes: Cannon meets in Utah about the AgJobs bill.” Click HERE for article.
Having just finished reading about the plight of the American farmer nearly 220 years ago regarding the need for “labor” inputs for agrabusiness in the Deep South and having my interest peaked by this headline in our local paper, I had to read on. The article primarily covers a meeting between Rep Chris Cannon (R-Utah) and a group of local agribusiness folks.
Congressman Cannon, speaking to over 20 farmers and ranchers in Provo, gave his support to the temporary amnesty, guest-worker program that, among other things, streamlines the process for alien migrant workers to obtain an H-2Avisa in as little as two weeks. Normally this process can take months.
“We have some pretty big (agricultural) operations in Utah, and it’s growing like crazy,” Cannon said. “You ought to be able to do that in a marketplace that’s predictable with a work force that is accessible.”
The article goes on to say, that “the bill is aimed at addressing a dire concern raised by a number of those who attended Tuesday’s meeting—that agriculture operations simply can’t find American workers who will work for what farmers can pay.”
In the article, Congressman Cannon said the bill has bipartisan and industry support.
Sound Familiar?
Now, many will ask me, “Rep Frank, how can you possibly compare the ‘Constitutionally’ condoned slave industry in Colonial times (1790) with the guest-worker, amnesty pilot program suggested and co-sponsored by Chris Cannon in the AgJobs bill currently under consideration by the US Congress?”
And, my answer would be…
Click HERE.